2012 Senior Art History Majors
Student Symposium Presentations
Other Projects
- "Perpetuating the
paragone and perfecting nature: Rubens's head of Medusa", Erin Daly
The Head of Medusa is
one of Rubens's most gruesome and violent products. In collaboration with Frans
Snyders, he presents a most impressive Medusa, one that, as Constantijn Huygens
said, is, “...done with such indescribable skill that it delights the viewer
who is overwhelmed with sudden terror by the very richness of the piece, as it
is lively and charming.” In Lisa Rosenthal's Gender, Politics, and Allegory
in the Art of Rubens, she acknowledges the original Latin construction of
Huygens' seemingly off-hand response to Head of Medusa, "viuida
venustaque delectet," which suggests two essential aspects of Medusa's
persona. Viuida means liveliness or spirited and invokes notions of
Medusa's "legendary powers" of regeneration, while the term venus captures
a nuanced sense of both her "charming" and "seductive"
qualities. It is aspects of the creative and feminine which are crucial to
understanding Rubens's domination and use of both.
Critical analyses have been
proposed by Rosenthal, who understands Rubens's role as hero artist triumphant,
wielder of the Medusa, and by Susan Koslow, who responds to misogynistic themes
in the portrait. Yet these are merely elements of a larger narrative structure,
and a link between their scholarship exists in Rubens's employment of his own
theory in relation to Head of Medusa as he engaged in the rhetoric
surrounding the paragone. By analyzing De Imitatione Statuarum and
its reflected principles found in the exterior and interior Rubens's own home,
the relationship between artist and perfection is illustrated. Almost
scientifically, the artist administers selective imitation, therein harnessing
nature and displaying perfection, a concept echoed in Rubens's naturelia and
sculpture gallery. Head of Medusa is the ultimate mimetic tool and
allows Rubens, as hero artist, to cultivate and perfect feminine
"nature" in order to address the paragone.